Post-Truth Regulation: Born in the USA, Coming of Age in Europe?
4 min to read

Post-Truth Regulation: Born in the USA, Coming of Age in Europe?

Date
February 03, 2017

Following Donald Trump’s dramatic and, some might say, surprising rise to power, questions remain as to the extent to which fake news stories such as “”Pope Francis Shocks World, Endorses Donald Trump for President, Releases Statement” may have influenced public opinion and even the election outcome.

Signs of the spread of the fake news epidemic are also emerging on this side of the Atlantic.  The UK Brexit referendum in June 2016 was dogged by allegations of exaggeration and outright dishonesty by both sides. Claims, for example, that the Remain campaign were conducting “Project Fear” to overplay the likely economic consequences of Brexit; and who can forget Boris Johnson’s battle-bus advertising the £350 million investment that could be made in the NHS if the Leavers emerged victorious?   Equally, during a referendum in Italy in December 2016, called to determine its Prime Minister’s proposals to reform the Italian political system, claims were made that half of all online news stories relating to the vote the day before it took place were in fact fake.

In 2017, government elections are due to take place in Germany, the Netherlands, France, Hungary, Slovenia and Norway.  In light of this, calls have begun in Europe for new regulation to monitor and address fake news stories, in the hope that limits can be imposed on this phenomenon, recently described by Givonanni Pitruzella (the head of Italy’s competition authority), in an interview with the Financial Times, as a “driver of populism” and a “threat to our democracies“.

Mr Pitruzella himself has proposed that each EU Member State should set up an independent body tasked with identifying and removing fake news, and imposing fines as appropriate.   Already in Germany, a law has been proposed that would oblige social media companies to set up dedicated local offices staffed with personnel to investigate and take action to remove (if necessary) fake news posts within 24 hours and would expose them to penalties of up to €500,000 per news items for failure to do so.   In response, Facebook and other social media sites have offered up voluntary steps they are implementing (such as the partnership announced by Facebook with third-party fact-checker Correctiv in Germany), presumably in the hope of staving off the full impact of heavier legislation.  Just a few days ago, European Commissioner Andrus Ansip announced that the EC would be closely following the voluntary steps taken by online platforms to tackle this challenge and would issue guidance later this year.

The tension arising from the fake news challenge can be seen as the latest chapter in the ongoing debate around liability for online content in Europe.  Key to taking advantage of the defences available to internet intermediaries under the E-Commerce Directive has been their ability to demonstrate that they play no active role in monitoring the content hosted on their sites.  Should legislation such as that threatened in Germany come into force, this may put paid to such arguments in the future and make it difficult for them to deny legal liability.

Whether the voluntary steps proposed by online platforms will suffice to assuage growing concerns in Europe around fake news remains to be seen.  As US internet companies continue to dominate, the mood in Europe does appear to be heading in one direction – as the German Minister for Justice put it recently “A company that earns billions from the Internet also has a social responsibility.”  However, the window for action by online platforms appears to not yet be closed; hinting at a reluctance to over-regulate, Ansip also remarked “fake news is bad, but the ministry of truth is even worse“.

Click here to read the full article on Bird & Bird’s MediaWrites blog.

Share
Written by
Bryony Hurst
Bryony Hurst
Bryony is a dispute resolution lawyer with a strong focus on media and technology disputes. Bryony advises clients on a broad range of litigation and arbitration ranging from complex contractual and tortious actions, regulatory matters and investigations, to privacy, defamation and breach of confidence disputes. She advises major film and broadcasting organisations, technology providers, website operators, internet intermediaries, sports clubs, sponsors and governing bodies on disputes spanning the commercial spectrum.
Related articles
Recent initiatives impacting the digital sector
Recent initiatives impacting the digital sector
Recent months have seen a veritable flurry of legislative, regulatory and soft law initiatives and proposals. The measures often tackle similar sectors – all things digital often being in the eye of the...
The EU considers allowing collective bargaining for gig workers
4 min to read
March 09, 2021
The EU considers allowing collective bargaining for gig workers
Over the past years, the EU institutions have shown quite some attention to the position of workers in the so-called gig or peer economy, despite the limited legislative authority of the EU in the area...
Bird & Bird Space & Satellite Bulletin: January 2021
2 min to read
January 31, 2021
Bird & Bird Space & Satellite Bulletin: January 2021
Bird & Bird’s international space and satellite activities sector group has published its latest International Space and Satellite Bulletin, which can be accessed following the link provided below....
Dutch competition authority focuses supervision on algorithmic applications
1 min to read
January 21, 2021
Dutch competition authority focuses supervision on algorithmic applications
On 10 December 2020, the Dutch Authority for Consumers & Markets ("ACM") published its position paper on the supervision of algorithmic applications (Position Paper on Supervision...
Cookies
We use analytics cookies to help us understand if our website is working well and to learn what content is most useful to visitors. We also use some cookies which are essential to make our website work. You can accept or reject our analytic cookies (including the collection of associated data) and change your mind at any time. Find out more in our Cookie Notice.